
ISLAM: A Simulation has no educational purpose, and it can serve
no educational function. From beginning to end, it is nothing but a
Muslim religious publication, produced by writers who seek to
exploit classroom teachers for propagating Islam.
From beginning to end, ISLAM: A Simulation directs teachers
to deceive their students and to boost Islam by disseminating lies
and by falsifying history. From beginning to end, ISLAM: A
Simulation requires teachers to indoctrinate their students by
feeding them servings of "information" in which historical facts are
insidiously intermixed with Muslim myths and Muslim woo-woo. From
beginning to end, ISLAM: A Simulation directs teachers to
present facts, myths and woo-woo as equivalent, equipotent items.
From beginning to end, ISLAM: A Simulation requires teachers
and students alike to abandon rationality, to shun analytical
thinking, and to embrace the view that any claim about anything --
no matter how fatuous the claim may be -- must be accepted as true.
These are the defining properties of ISLAM: A Simulation, and
I shall analyze them, later, in some detail. First, however, I must
devote a few paragraphs to a lesser but significant feature of
Interact's document: It is so heavily loaded with anachronisms that
it has no sense of time.
Most of ISLAM: A Simulation is built around a religious
farce in which students, directed by their teacher, pretend to be
Muslims who are living during the time of Muhammad (i.e., early in
the 7th century). The students adopt "Islamic" names, don "Islamic"
clothing, and form six teams representing the "early Islamic cities"
of Cairo, Jerusalem, Medina, Damascus, Baghdad and Cordova. Then
each team acquires an imaginary caravan of camels, and the six teams
engage in a caravan-race from Cordova to Mecca. The race fills five
days of class time, and each team's progress on each day depends
upon the team's success in collecting and reciting "information"
about Islam. A note to the teacher says, "Clearly, this race
intensifies the rivalry [among teams] and will probably heighten
enthusiasm at the same time."
Enthusiasm for what? Enthusiasm for seeing camels drown as they
try to walk across the Strait of Gibraltar? Enthusiasm for
believing that Cordova was an Islamic city in the early years of the
7th century, even though the Muslim invasion of the Iberian
Peninsula didn't begin until the second decade of the 8th
century?
The mislabeling of 7th-century Cordova as an Islamic city is but one
of a multitude of anachronisms found in ISLAM: A Simulation.
During the caravan-race, students who supposedly are driving camels
through the 7th century receive bulletins such as "While in
Damascus, you are inspired by the Great Mosque" and "While in
Damascus you are attacked by Christian crusaders" -- but the mosque
at Damascus wasn't built until the 8th century, and the crusades
didn't begin until the closing years of the 11th. The caravanners
also learn factoids such as "Of the former Soviet Union's 15
republics, six have primarily Muslim populations" and "Arabic music has
influenced famous composers, such as Bartok and Stravinsky" -- but
those statements wouldn't have made any sense at all, to anyone, in
the 7th century. When the students make "Muslim food," they use
recipes that call for peanuts and tomatoes -- but the peanut and the
tomato, which originated in the New World, were not seen in the Old
World till the 1500s. And so on, and so on.
I don't want to belabor this matter, but I do want you to know that
ISLAM: A Simulation, which purports to enable teachers to
inform their students about "history," is ahistorical and indeed
antihistorical. It is an antihistorical mishmash, hastily assembled to
serve as a platform for religious indoctrination. Now I'll show
you how this indoctrination is supposed to work.
Phase 1, "Introduction," takes one day. During this phase, the
classroom teacher assigns his students to their city-teams, leads
them through the adoption of their "Islamic" names and their
"Islamic" clothes [see note 1, below], and gives them a handout
which includes an Islamic prayer [note 2 and note 3]. Then the teacher distributes a handout titled "ISLAM: A History" (pages 1:22 through 1:26).
The "History" handout is a fraud. Here are some of the items that
it presents as history:
Now you understand what I meant when I said that ISLAM: A
Simulation requires teachers to deceive their students, to feed
them servings of "information" in which historical facts are
insidiously intermixed with Muslim myths and Muslim woo-woo, and to
present facts, myths and woo-woo as equivalent items. When students
read the "History" handout, they learn that Muhammad received divine
revelations -- and they learn that this is history, and they learn
that there is no qualitative difference between a claim about divine
revelations and a claim about the size of the Arabian Peninsula.
When students read the handout, they learn that the Kaaba was built
by Adam -- and they learn that this is history, and they learn that
a myth about Adam is no different from a statement about the
geography of Yemen.
The "History" handout thus reflects the grand indoctrination
strategy that Interact's writers use throughout ISLAM: A
Simulation. Their strategy is to turn students into true
believers by turning them into fools -- fools who will be unable to
recognize the difference between a fact and a superstition, unable
to distinguish a statement that is supported by evidence from a
statement that isn't, and unable to distinguish a claim that can be
tested from a claim that can't. This strategy pervades the writers'
efforts to recruit converts for Allah, and it is implemented with
great vigor and viciousness in Phase 2.
The Wisdom Cards are divided into three categories -- Truth, Fact,
and Trivia. On each card, some prose that deals with Islam or with
Arabia is followed by the label Truth or the label
Fact or the label Trivia. No other labels are used.
Here, as examples, are the items displayed on six of the Truth
cards:
The symbol of Muslims is the crescent moon and star. Truth
Archangel Gabriel came to Prophet Muhammad while he meditated in a
cave and revealed
The Umayyad Dynasty lasted from 661 to 750. Truth
The Kaaba in Makkah is the holiest shrine of Islam. It was
originally built by Adam
The Qur'an is the sacred book of Islam.
Truth
Here are the items displayed on six of the Fact cards:
The Qur'an has 114 chapters or suras, has 6,226 verses, and is God's
third revelation
Islamic art is usually calligraphy, designs, and patterns.
Fact
Islam forbids the drinking of alcohol. Fact
Indonesia is the world's largest Muslim nation in population.
Fact
Jinns, who were created from fire, can be good or evil, with the
chief evil jinn
And here are the items displayed on six of the Trivia cards:
Prophet Muhammad first began to receive revelations from God at the
age of 40. Trivia
Of the former Soviet Union's 280 million people, more than 20% are
Muslims. Trivia
The Arabic alphabet is read from right to left and is made up of 28
symbols. Trivia
There are about 11.5 million Muslims in America. Trivia
The holy books of Islam, Christianity, and Judaism all have much of
the same history, stories, and beliefs.
Trivia
Whenever a team wins a Wisdom Card, the teacher reads the content of
the card aloud. No matter which team wins the Kaaba card, the
teacher reads aloud that "The Black Stone came down from heaven with
Adam" -- and all the students on all the teams learn that this is a
Truth, no different from the Truth that "People who believe in Islam
are called Muslims." No matter which team wins the Jinns card, the
teacher proclaims that Satan and the other jinns were created from
fire -- and all the students learn that this is a Fact, no different
from the Fact that "Islam forbids the drinking of alcohol." By
requiring the teacher to read every card aloud, Interact's writers
ensure that all the students on all the teams will receive full and
equal doses of religious indoctrination.
The division of the Wisdom Cards into the categories Truth, Fact,
and Trivia merits attention, for this categorization is itself an
indoctrination device. Notice first that the categorization is
phony. Interact's writers falsely treat Truth, Fact and Trivia as
three discrete, mutually exclusive classes -- in other words, they
claim that a truth can't be a fact, that a fact can't be a truth,
and that neither a truth nor a fact can be trivial. Those
propositions are bogus. The writers have invented their phony
categories to confuse students, to create opportunities for applying
the label Truth to statements that aren't true, and to create
opportunities for applying the label Fact to statements that
aren't facts at all.
Now notice this: By equipping every card with the label Truth
or the label Fact or the label Trivia, the writers
have excluded all other descriptors and have sought to render
students blind to all other possibilities. If students were
permitted to think, and were permitted to choose labels of their
own, the brighter students might come up with False or
Myth or Superstition or Folktale or Lie
-- but there is no room in Interact's program for allowing students
to think.
There is, however, ample room for forcing the students to swallow
lies, and some of the statements conveyed on the Wisdom Cards --
whether labeled as Truth or as Fact or as
Trivia -- are quite false. As examples, recall the last two
Trivia items that I quoted above:
The Quiz Cards that students encounter during Caravan Days
reinforce the indoctrination which the Interact writers, using the
teacher as their patsy, have delivered on the Wisdom Cards and
(during Phase 1) on the "History" handout. When a student responds
properly to a Quiz Card, his city-team wins five dirhams of "Arabic
money" as a prize, and this helps the team to advance in the
caravan-race to Mecca [note 9].
Here are the items that appear on ten of the Quiz Cards. Again we
see the deceptive intermixing of factual material with religious
claims and woo-woo:
Nomads of the desert are called ________.
The holiest article of the Kaaba in Makkah is called the ________.
The Arabic term for the pilgrimage to Makkah is ________.
Islam prohibits the drinking of ________.
The body of water along the western edge of Saudi Arabia is
________.
Prophet Muhammad was called by God while meditating here: ________.
The most important animal for early Arabs was the ________.
This was brought down from heaven by Adam: ________.
Shaded area with water in the desert: ________.
Interact's writers, with the help of their patsy, have made a good
start in their effort to turn students into fools. That effort will
continue in Phase 3.
At the start of Phase 3, the members of each team pick two or more
projects that they will develop into Festival Presentations. The
Festival Presentations will be delivered during Phase 4.
Interact's writers provide a list of 37 suggested projects, such as
these:
Prepare a play or discussion on the mystic Islamic group -- Sufis.
Prepare a presentation on the Five Pillars of Faith.
Prepare a presentation on the dromedary or camel, use slides,
pictures, etc.
Create a newspaper with headlines, photos, and articles.
Design a title page for the Qur'an using the proper designs and
writings. Then present information on the Qur'an itself.
Make a large tapestry [!] with Arabic scenes or perhaps verses from
the Qur'an.
Make and explain some examples of Arabic jewelry and describe the
significance.
Build a replica of the sacred Kaaba or a mosque or minaret. Present
information on the symbolism of Islamic architecture and a history
of the building you're presenting.
Become a Muslim warrior during the crusades or during an ancient
jihad. Explain weapons, tactics, etc.
After picking their projects, the students turn their attention to
Islam's Five Pillars of Faith -- professing, praying, fasting,
practicing charity, and making a pilgrimage to Mecca. To profess
their faith, the members of each city-team make a banner displaying
the name of their city and the Bismillah. (The Bismillah is the
Koran's opening invocation -- "In the name of God, the merciful, the
compassionate.") To simulate praying, each member of the team must
memorize five proverbs (chosen from a list of proverbs on page 3:12)
and must "analyze" at least one verse of the Koran (chosen from a
list on pages 3:13 and 3:14). To simulate fasting, "each group
should give up one lunch or snack period to work on their Festival
Presentation." To practice charity, "Each person in the group must
provide one service for one of the following: community, school,
faculty, administration, rival group." There is no simulation of
the fifth Pillar, the pilgrimage to Mecca: On page 3:10 the Interact writers
say that the caravan-race fulfills the requirement for a pilgrimage.
Next comes a lengthy role-playing activity in which selected
students impersonate six Muslims who were prominent at various
times between the middle of the 7th century and the middle of the 11th
century [note 10]. Each of
these six celebrities visits each of the
city-teams and answers questions. A script on page 3:27 provides
the questions that must be posed to each celebrity, and "profile
sheets" on pages through 3:15 through 3:26 provide the material that
the celebrities will use in fashioning their replies. Each
celebrity's visit to each group ends with the prayer "Jazaak Allahu
khairun (may God bless you with the best of his rewards). Ma'a
salama (go with peace)."
The last segment of Phase 3 is titled "Introduction to Prophet
Muhammad." Now it is the teacher's turn to play a role -- the role
of a 7th-century person who was a friend of Muhammad. While the
students sit on simulated prayer rugs (which they have made by
drawing abstract designs on large sheets of paper), the teacher
preaches to them, voices devotional slogans [note 11], and presents
twenty items of "information." The twenty items are supplied to the
teacher on pages 3:6 and 3:7, in question-and-answer form. Here are
eight of them:
Who were his mother and father and what clan and tribe was he
from? Prophet Muhammad's father died before he was born.
His name was Abdullah and was a trader from the clan of Hashim,
which belonged to the powerful tribe of the Quraysh. His mother's
name was Amina.
After Prophet Muhammad was orphaned, at age six, who raised
him? After Prophet Muhammad's mother died he was raised
by his grandfather, Abdul Muttalib, who died two years later. He
was then raised by his paternal uncle, Abu Talib, who reared him to
manhood.
Prophet Muhammad is God's messenger and the final prophet. How
did God reveal His Message to him? God revealed His
Message to Prophet Muhammad through revelations and through Angel
Gabriel. They were written down during his lifetime and became the
Holy Qur'an.
What will hell or heaven be like? According to the
Qur'an, Heaven will be a vast garden in which believers will be
shaded with large trees, dressed in silks, adorned with gems, and
fed fruit by rivers of milk and honey. Hell will be filled with
burning heat, your shoes will be made of fire, and you will drink
boiling water.
Why is the sacred Kaaba in Makkah so important?
Originally built by Adam, who brought the Black Stone down with him
from Paradise, the Kaaba in Makkah was later rebuilt by Abraham and
his first son, Ismail. It is here that Muslims must make the hajj
pilgrimage once in their lifetime if they are physically and
financially able to do so.
Did Prophet Muhammad ever dream that Islam would be the second
largest religion in the world? He was always sure that
Islam was the world's most important religion.
Can you describe the occasion when Prophet Muhammad visited in
heaven? God transported Prophet Muhammad to Jerusalem
where he ascended from the Dome of the Rock to heaven upon the grand
horse, Buraq.
The mundane statements that constitute the first three items may
look like history, but they actually are Muslim myths that have no
historical foundation. Practically nothing is known about
Muhammad's life before he set himself up as a prophet. Even the
claim that he was born and reared in Mecca is unsupported by
evidence [note 12].
The fourth item, too, is quite mythical, including the claim that
Muhammad's "revelations" were "written down during his lifetime and
became the Holy Qur'an." The origins and development of the Koran
are obscure, to say the least. The Koran didn't appear until the
closing years of the 7th century, decades after Muhammad died -- and
even then, apparently, its content hadn't been fixed [note 13].
The fifth and sixth items don't require comment; and the seventh
item, in which the prescribed "answer" obviously fails to meet the
question, is remarkable only for its silliness. The eighth item,
however, is a doozie that incorporates one of the Interact writers'
most laughable anachronisms. According to Muslim lore, Muhammad
died in 632 -- but the construction of the Dome of the Rock, the
great Muslim temple in Jerusalem, didn't begin until 685 or so, and
it wasn't completed until 691. Flying horse or no flying horse,
Muhammad couldn't have made any journeys, to anywhere, from the Dome
of the Rock.
Phase 5, the climax of ISLAM: A Simulation, is titled
"Islamic Bowl." The Islamic Bowl is a one-day contest, "designed to
review important information," in which selected members of the six
city-teams compete for dirhams by trying to answer questions posed
by the teacher. The questions come from the Quiz Cards that were
used in Phase 2 -- so the class learns again that "Allah is the only
true God and Muhammad is his prophet," that Muhammad was called by
God while meditating in a cave, that the Black Stone was brought
down from heaven by Adam, and so forth.
At the finish of the Islamic Bowl, the teacher announces the name of
the city-team that has won, and then the teacher declares: "That's
all we have time for. So until next time, 'in sha Allah, assalam
aleikoom and Allahu akbar (God willing, may peace be with you, and
there is none greater than God Almighty)'."
I have seen various schoolbooks and curriculum manuals which have
been designed to deceive students, but I cannot cite any other
product in which outright lies and other devices of deceit are as
strongly concentrated as they are in ISLAM: A Simulation.
This document's malignancy transcends mere deceit, however, for the
Interact writers have used their lies and other devices to mount a
sustained attack on rationality itself.
I have sought to emphasize, in this review, that Interact's program
requires a great deal of promotion and participation by the
classroom teacher -- the teacher who must serve as Interact's dupe,
must carry out Interact's instructions for bamboozling and deluding
students, and must even recount a flying-horse legend as if it were
history. I now assert that any teacher who would do such things
should be sacked forthwith. I assert that any teacher who would
have anything to do with ISLAM: A Simulation should be fired
before the day is out. ISLAM: A Simulation has no place in
any legitimate school, and neither does any teacher who is so
ignorant and so stupid that he cannot recognize Interact's manual of
rubbish for what it is.
The first page of Interact's manual carries an introductory
statement which acknowledges that two Muslim agencies were involved
in the genesis of ISLAM: A Simulation. The names of the
agencies are given as "the Islamic Education and Information Center
(San Jose, California)" and "the Council of [sic] Islamic
Education (Los Angeles)."
I haven't encountered the Islamic Education and Information Center
heretofore, but I know of the second outfit -- the Council on
Islamic Education -- because its name appears in several
schoolbooks that falsify the history of Islam, spread Muslim
propaganda, and subject students to Muslim indoctrination. One such
book is Across the Centuries
[note 14], published by Houghton
Mifflin: The list of "Consultants" displayed on the copyright page
of Across the Centuries includes "Shabbir Mansuri, Founding
Director, Council on Islamic Education, Fountain Valley,
California." Another such book is Prentice Hall World History:
Connections to Today [note 15].
The list of "Content Reviewers"
on page iv of Prentice Hall World History: Connections to
Today includes "Shabbir Mansuri, Director, Council on Islamic
Education, Fountain Valley, California" and another CIE luminary,
Susan Douglass [note 16].
Notes
William J. Bennetta is a professional editor, a fellow of the
California Academy of Sciences, the president of The Textbook
League, and the editor of The Textbook Letter. He writes
often about the propagation of quackery, false "science" and false
"history" in schoolbooks.
Reviewing a fraudulent curriculum manual
ISLAM:
A Simulation of Islamic History and Culture, 610-1100
1991. ISBN: 1-57336-074-0. Interaction Publishers, Inc. (DBA "Interact"),
5937 Darwin Court, Suite 106, Carlsbad, California 92008.
Page for Page, This Is the Most Malignant Product
That I've Seen During All My Years as a ReviewerWilliam J. Bennetta
ISLAM: A Simulation of Islamic History and Culture, 610-1100
is produced and marketed by Interaction Publishers, of Carlsbad,
California. This corporation, which does business under the name
"Interact" (and refers to itself by that name), promotes ISLAM: A
Simulation as a curriculum manual for history teachers in
grades 6 through 12. ISLAM: A Simulation consists of lesson
plans and handouts for a three-week program of classroom instruction
in which students "will simulate becoming Muslims" and allegedly
"will learn about the history and culture of Islam." The lesson
plans and handouts occupy 114 printed pages, contained in a
loose-leaf binder.
A Deceitful Handout
The area in southwest Asia, between the Red Sea and
the Persian Gulf, is called the Arabian Peninsula. . . .
Largely a desert region, the peninsula stretches [sic] for
about a million and a quarter square miles. Some areas, such as
Yemen, feature well-watered fertile mountains in its [sic]
interior. . . . Before and after the establishment of Islam,
many Arabs were Bedouins, or nomads of the desert. . . .
Before God revealed His message to Prophet Muhammad, the Arabs
worshiped many gods. . . . When Prophet Muhammad was 25, he
married Khadija, a rich widow. . . . While meditating in a
cave in the desert, he had a vision of an angel. He was told by the
angel Gabriel to be the apostle of God and to "warn" the people. . .
. God's revelations were written down over a period of 23
years which today constitute the Qur'an [Koran], the holy book of
Muslims. . . . There are more than one billion Muslims . . .
. Africa has the largest number of Muslims; followed by
India. The biggest predominantly Muslim country is Indonesia. . .
. During the Hajj [a religious pilgrimage to Mecca], Muslims
are required to visit the ancient shrine of the Kaaba. The Kaaba is
a large cubelike structure in the center of the courtyard of the
Holy Mosque in Makkah [Mecca]. The Kaaba, originally built by Adam
as the first building to glorify God, was later rebuilt by Abraham
and his son Ismail [note 4].
Labels and Lies
People who believe in Islam are called Muslims.
Truth
God's word to him. Revelations continued for 23 years.
Truth
and later rebuilt by Abraham and his son, Ismail. The Black Stone
came down from heaven
with Adam and was placed by him in the southeastern corner of the
Kaaba. Truth [note 5]
Throughout the Islamic World, the faithful are called
to prayer by a muezzin, sometimes
with a loud speaker. Fact
that was revealed to Prophet Muhammad. Fact
being "Iblis" or Satan. Fact [note 6]Islam uses a lunar calendar. Trivia
Complete this phrase: "Allah is the only true God and
Muhammad is his ________."
Pillars, Prayer Rugs, and a Flying Horse Too!
Create a play, poem or presentation on the life of
the ancient Bedouins or nomads of the desert.
When and where was Prophet Muhammad
born? Prophet Muhammad was born in 570 in Makkah, which
is about halfway down western Arabia near the Red Sea. He was
called al-Amin -- "the trustworthy man," and his Arabic name means
"highly praised."
The Black Stone Again
Transcendent Malignancy
Interact's Links to Muslim Agencies
In the name of God, Most Gracious,
Most Merciful.
Praise be to God, The Cherisher
and Sustainer of
the Worlds;
Most Gracious, Most Merciful;
Master of the Day of Judgment;
Thee do we worship,
And Thine aid we seek,
Show us the straight path,
The way on [sic] those whom Thou
hast bestowed Thy
Grace.
Those whose portion is not wrath,
And who go not astray.
Amen
[return to text]